(Note: Cheap Trophies was accepted for publishing in “Here Comes Everyone,” at Silhouette Press. http://silhouettepress.co.uk/here-comes-everyone/, on October 3, 2017.)
A program infused with unfinished parents who benefit from recognition they never received, live through their progeny. “Wow, he’s really fast aye Joe, aren’t you proud of him this year?” What a shrewd combination of organizational Machiavellianism. Don’t upset the apple cart of taxpayers in the coliseum. Level the playing field for little Johnnies and Jennies. Everyone plays the same amount of time; play well with others regardless of accomplishment. Breathing, sleeping, and stuffing their faces with pizza and ice cream qualifies them for triumphant nobility, each participant equal.
The expected outcome measures: good sportsmanship, teamwork, and lots of hedonism. Eager parents and family members jump to their feet yelling and clapping like they scored a damn touchdown themselves, like they own the joint. They smile at each other in the stands tugging at the front of their jersey, smiling, taking selfies with their son/daughter to show what remarkable natives they are. It becomes a family affair.
Do we overvalue our abilities? It turns into a breathtaking delusional clap-fuck jamboree. The Todd Marinovich story illustrates the situation all too well. His obsessed father and he eventually crashed and burned in front of the sporting world. Recognition through offspring, young players are acknowledged for being contestants, they are lied to, coerced into believing they are marvelous and worthy of the goods, worthy of hardware, when all are not. Something given not earned, someone they may never ever become, and the few talented enough to get things done, sit idle staring at cheap aluminum alloy trophies. The weakest link pulls up the rear like an anchor dangling at sea. I remember my Marine DI yelling, “You are only as quick as your slowest rifleman in this God damn platoon. That piece of shit will drag the unit down into the depths of hell and get us all killed.”
We reward participants for being malfunctions, for showing up with nice grins. “Just tell me coach, please,” urgently, as my plastic mouthpiece dangles with blood and saliva. Tell me the truth; tell me now so I can quit wasting time and expensive tape! Tell me so I can move on to Art History or Classic Philosophy, or English Literature, or something that I am passionate about spending my one precious life doing. Tell me I am nothing, tell my parents, tell the team I am too small, tell me I can’t tackle for shit, tell me I have heavy ankles that no amount of training will develop without a complete reincarnation. Tell me I am not good enough, I am weak, or run-of-the-mill, or whatever the fuck, but don’t put me in the same container with the whole team, with the same handling and credit when there are exceptional ones out there. Outstanding ones with bones and ligaments that strike the turf in perfect harmony like piano keys hitting fine-tuned strings, with hands that make love to a pigskin as it touches their fingers after a post route, or like deer that glide over barbwire fences in a dark snowy wood. Exceptional ones that move like thoroughbreds with sinews and muscles intermingling with the gods, with eyes that respond as swift as an eagle, and the roughness of a proven warrior. Expose the obvious, for their future’s sake, not for the expectations of a group of whiners. Listen carefully coach, if you don’t they will look back in twenty years with tears in their eyes because of the lies. The process misrepresents and interrupts mental development of the young player. It creates an erroneous paradise, lost in translation, pointing towards a selfish empire where mythical idols are devoted and lifted up high on shoulders, high above the coliseum. Taking part in sacrifice does not equate to being an expert gunner. The true definition sits idle at the base of the mountain, waiting to be discovered by the few who are willing to pay the high price. A systemic sequence based on Sisyphean struggle. Character traits do not show up with fuzzy blankets and warm milk one sunny day.
My coach in college used to growl at the end of each practice, “Men, the top eleven athletes will be on my field at any given time and place, if you don’t like it, get the hell out.” Fresh cut grass, sweaty durable young men breathing as labored as quarter horses, and the gritty odor lingering behind the steel bars of my face mask like Dostoyevsky in that Siberian prison. There was always someone at your door, starving and hungry like the wolf. Who in the hell ever said the process is emotionally and physically free of pain or disappointment. Developmental authority comes with a cost. Cognitive and physical anguish makes things come alive. Achievement in youth sports is not for everyone. There is no clear-cut path to pure enlightenment. The risks, wrecks, deaths, bruises, moans, losses, smiles, and broken bones, prove how powerful the playing field can be.
Each practice session or game is structurally designed to place a probe in the mind of the player, to find something out about the player’s wiring, about the true level of character from the coaches’ viewpoint, not the parents. For the most part, fathers/mothers act as though their Johnny/Jenny should be detached from all emotional pain, shame, and suffering. Under competitive pressure, some explode with glory and others fall on their sword. The glaring truth is that diamonds are made over long periods of time by pressure. A mixed stew of tough circumstances, defeats, conquests, playing time, second stringers, scrap heaps, frustration, joy, and fellowship is part of the package. Perhaps when they are 50, holding a glass of bourbon in one fist, and that cheap ass two-dollar trophy in the other, they will think about their own participation story, about the worth of those cheap gestures. How it felt to be given something for just being there. They will think about how mediocrity whirled around them, how it provoked them, how life is not fair, and never will be. Don’t tell them lies.